26 August 2007

Romanovs?

I've been fascinated by the Romanovs for a long time now. It was in junior high that I first read Anastasia: The Riddle of Anna Anderson and Nicholas and Alexandra. They started me on a quest to learn more about this family. When I read, I am a character. Maybe that's the actress in me...or maybe it's just the ME in me. I have a need to strongly identify with one character and read from there. I like Anastasia. She intrigues me. And, I'll openly admit that Anna Anderson has me firmly in her camp. I don't care what they say--I'm a believer.

You know the horribly tragic story, I'm sure. The royal family was taken captive in 1917 by the Bolsheviks, eventually transferred to Ekaterinburg, and finally executed along with their few remaining servants. But, things get a little murky. There are confusing and conflicting reports, many of which sound like flimsy excuses for incompetence. (Seriously--why would they bury two of the bodies in a different place? Why? And, even if they did, why those two? Why not the tsar and tsarevich? This separate burial scheme alone makes no sense. I won't even get started on all the inconsistencies and ridiculous suppositions that have been accepted by some as fact.)

There was a report in The Guardian yesterday as well as in other news sources about the finding of the potential remains of Tsarevitch Alexei Romanov and one of his sisters that have been missing since the rest of the family's remains were supposedly found. (There is controversy about whether or not the first set of bones actually belonged to the Tsar and his family.)

I don't really have a nice summation for this post. I think you should go and read the article. I think you should also go and read some of the original evidence about the last days of the Romanov family. (It was all saved--though not methodically or carefully--and notes from various parties involved are still available today.) You can read some historical fiction if your prefer and latch on to that, though, naturally, there is more author's pov to wade through in that genre than in non-fiction; although non-fiction doesn't mean unbiased. (The Romanov Prophecy is a quick-reading thriller. I didn't like The Kitchen Boy. Post your favs in the comments!) Then, you can decide for yourself.

9 comments:

Holly said...

I read that book when I was younger too and have also been fascinated by the story. There's even a movie with Melissa Gilbert as the title character and the story loosely captures the story of Anastasia, or at least what may have happened to her. The movie is called "Zoya"...just looked it up, it's based on a book by Danielle Steele, but honestly it does resemble the Romanov story.

Anyway, such a tragic story isn't it?

Rachael said...

Have you read the one I'm reading now? "The Romanovs: the Final Chapter" by Robert K. Massie. It's a fairly scientific look at all the evidence, but not a difficult read. It's VERY interesting. I'm about 2/3 through. I'm JUST coming to the part about Anna Anderson. It sounds like the scientists pretty effectively are going to discredit her in the book with DNA tests, etc. But, I love the IDEA that Anastasia escaped, too.

Anonymous said...

I am so telling Zach about this article. You know, my son's name was influenced by that family...man, we're so unique.

Suzanne said...

ohhh - you've inspired a post -- thx

Tami said...

The Romanovs have fascinated me since we first started looking into adopting from Russia. I have to admit my opinion is horribly ill-informed, but it is awfully romantic to think of Anastasia tempting fate and escaping ot another country. I need to do more research! :) Thanks for the inspiration!

Calico Sky said...

I too have been obsessed with the story!
Carrie, I too watched Zoya!

Lea said...

Count me in. I read The Last Tsar - The Life and Death of Nicholas II by Edvard Radzinsky years ago and thoroughly enjoyed it. Very tragic but also very interesting. The book Rachael mentions sounds like a good. I might just have to get that book.

Do you think there is a general consensus in Russia about what happened to Anastasia?

Lea said...

Just read that article. I wouldn't think that the DNA tests would be very conclusive, since they are comparing to a distant relative. From what I have read about adoptive parents trying to do DNA testing to find siblings of adopted children, it is very difficult, if not impossible, without the DNA of the parents. If that is the case, I would think the DNA testing they have done would not be very reliable.

Allison said...

I too am absessed with the Romanovs. I loved Nicholas and Alexandra and thought The Romanovs: The Final Chapter by Massie was great too.